Andrew Cooke | Contents | Latest | RSS | Previous | Next


Welcome to my blog, which was once a mailing list of the same name and is still generated by mail. Please reply via the "comment" links.

Always interested in offers/projects/new ideas. Eclectic experience in fields like: numerical computing; Python web; Java enterprise; functional languages; GPGPU; SQL databases; etc. Based in Santiago, Chile; telecommute worldwide. CV; email.

Personal Projects

Choochoo Training Diary

Last 100 entries

[Programming] React Leaflet; AliExpress Independent Sellers; Applebaum - Twilight of Democracy; [Politics] Back + US Elections; [Programming,Exercise] Simple Timer Script; [News] 2019: The year revolt went global; [Politics] The world's most-surveilled cities; [Bike] Hope Freehub; [Restaurant] Mama Chau's (Chinese, Providencia); [Politics] Brexit Podcast; [Diary] Pneumonia; [Politics] Britain's Reichstag Fire moment; install cairo; [Programming] GCC Sanitizer Flags; [GPU, Programming] Per-Thread Program Counters; My Bike Accident - Looking Back One Year; [Python] Geographic heights are incredibly easy!; [Cooking] Cookie Recipe; Efficient, Simple, Directed Maximisation of Noisy Function; And for argparse; Bash Completion in Python; [Computing] Configuring Github Jekyll Locally; [Maths, Link] The Napkin Project; You can Masquerade in Firewalld; [Bike] Servicing Budget (Spring) Forks; [Crypto] CIA Internet Comms Failure; [Python] Cute Rate Limiting API; [Causality] Judea Pearl Lecture; [Security, Computing] Chinese Hardware Hack Of Supermicro Boards; SQLAlchemy Joined Table Inheritance and Delete Cascade; [Translation] The Club; [Computing] Super Potato Bruh; [Computing] Extending Jupyter; Further HRM Details; [Computing, Bike] Activities in ch2; [Books, Link] Modern Japanese Lit; What ended up there; [Link, Book] Logic Book; Update - Garmin Express / Connect; Garmin Forerunner 35 v 230; [Link, Politics, Internet] Government Trolls; [Link, Politics] Why identity politics benefits the right more than the left; SSH Forwarding; A Specification For Repeating Events; A Fight for the Soul of Science; [Science, Book, Link] Lost In Math; OpenSuse Leap 15 Network Fixes; Update; [Book] Galileo's Middle Finger; [Bike] Chinese Carbon Rims; [Bike] Servicing Shimano XT Front Hub HB-M8010; [Bike] Aliexpress Cycling Tops; [Computing] Change to ssh handling of multiple identities?; [Bike] Endura Hummvee Lite II; [Computing] Marble Based Logic; [Link, Politics] Sanity Check For Nuclear Launch; [Link, Science] Entropy and Life; [Link, Bike] Cheap Cycling Jerseys; [Link, Music] Music To Steal 2017; [Link, Future] Simulated Brain Drives Robot; [Link, Computing] Learned Index Structures; Solo Air Equalization; Update: Higher Pressures; Psychology; [Bike] Exercise And Fuel; Continental Race King 2.2; Removing Lowers; Mnesiacs; [Maths, Link] Dividing By Zero; [Book, Review] Ray Monk - Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Duty Of Genius; [Link, Bike, Computing] Evolving Lacing Patterns; [Jam] Strawberry and Orange Jam; [Chile, Privacy] Biometric Check During Mail Delivery; [Link, Chile, Spanish] Article on the Chilean Drought; [Bike] Extended Gear Ratios, Shimano XT M8000 (24/36 Chainring); [Link, Politics, USA] The Future Of American Democracy; Mass Hysteria; [Review, Books, Links] Kazuo Ishiguro - Never Let Me Go; [Link, Books] David Mitchell's Favourite Japanese Fiction; [Link, Bike] Rear Suspension Geometry; [Link, Cycling, Art] Strava Artwork; [Link, Computing] Useful gcc flags; [Link] Voynich Manuscript Decoded; [Bike] Notes on Servicing Suspension Forks; [Links, Computing] Snap, Flatpack, Appimage; [Link, Computing] Oracle is leaving Java (to die); [Link, Politics] Cubans + Ultrasonics; [Book, Link] Laurent Binet; VirtualBox; [Book, Link] No One's Ways; [Link] The Biggest Problem For Cyclists Is Bad Driving; [Computing] Doxygen, Sphinx, Breathe; [Admin] Brokw Recent Permalinks; [Bike, Chile] Buying Bearings in Santiago; [Computing, Opensuse] Upgrading to 42.3; [Link, Physics] First Support for a Physics Theory of Life; [Link, Bike] Peruvian Frame Maker; [Link] Awesome Game Theory Tit-For-Tat Thing; [Food, Review] La Fabbrica - Good Italian Food In Santiago; [Link, Programming] MySQL UTF8 Broken; [Link, Books] Latin American Authors

© 2006-2017 Andrew Cooke (site) / post authors (content).

Control and Feedback in the Central Nervous System

From: andrew cooke <andrew@...>

Date: Fri, 5 Jul 2013 20:02:51 -0400

[Before I start, a disclaimer - this is just my attempt to place a structure
on recent experiences.  I am not a medical expert, at all.]

A single "cycle" of (recurrent) MS consists of a short "outbreak", when the
immune system attacks your nervous system, followed by a much longer recovery
phase, during which many of the nerves are repaired.  Experiencing this is,
amongst other things, interesting, because it gives you some insight into how
the central nervous system (CNS) works.

So what I will do below is list various experiences, and then try to link
things together, into a coherent description.

1 - You don't feel much when things go wrong.  The best analogy I have for the
    damage done to nerves is that it's similar to removing the insulation from
    electrical cable.  In an electrical system that likely gives you noise -
    in a biological system what you feel is pins and needles (without the
    painful part that seems to be part of pins and needles when you restrict
    blood flow to your leg, for example - it's just the tingly feeling).

    In addition, you feel various muscles as "lumps" or "sausages" inside your
    body.  As far as I can make out this is the best interpretation that the
    conscious mind can make of inconsistent signals, when some (working)
    nerves detect the presence of a nearby muscle, but the (damaged) nerves in
    that muscle are silent.

    But what you don't feel is a gap.  There's no feeling of "whoa, I can't
    feel X", unless you are making some conscious effort to sense something.
    So if your fingers are numb, and you rub your hand across a rough cloth,
    you might think "huh, I can't feel that".  But otherwise, there's no "my
    fingers aren't sending the usual data" feeling.

2 - Sensing and control seem to be separate.  Damage to the CNS occurs in
    specific locations (lesions).  So if that's physically where nerves for
    your arm are, then your arm is going to lose both control and feeling.
    But at a finer scale, feeling and control seem to be decoupled.  Some
    parts of your arm might be numb, but still move just fine, for example.

3 - There's redundancy and overlap.  One of the more unusual experiences as
    nerves in your legs recover is hyper-awareness that you're wearing
    trousers.  When nerves that feel their presence "turn on" again, the
    signal is initially way too loud (presumably because it is new; it decays
    to normal levels in a day or so).  So you are over-aware of these hot,
    restrictive, uncomfortable nappy (diaper)-like things.

    And this (unmistakable) feeling occurs multiple times.  Which, as far as I
    can see, means that multiple circuits are basically detecting the same

4 - For a long time (~3 months) I was unable to run / jog for more than 15
    minutes.  After that, I was completely exhausted.  Not physically
    exhausted - more a weird kind of emotional / mental exhaustion.

    Then, one day, it went away, and I could run further.

5 - The process of recovery takes a long time (for me, things are still
    improving after 8 months), but appears mainly as very localized
    improvements: single muscles aching or twitching; localized pins and
    needles; return of feeling in a small area; appearance or disappearance of
    a "sausage"; etc.  The "big" improvements, like being able to walk up and
    down stairs smoothly, or being able to run for more than 15 minutes, are
    much more infrequent (and seem to be sudden, rather than gradual).

6 - You want to sleep at various points during the day.  This seems to be a
    very common symptom.  I was already good at napping, so it's not really
    bothered me, but at least twice a day I will spend 15-20m asleep (before,
    you feel really tired; after, you feel great).

OK, so here comes the synthesis...

All the above seems to fit well with a two layer model.  The "upper" layer
would be a negative-feedback system - if you want to move your legs, it sends
out commands, then receives back reports, calculates the error, and corrects.
The "lower" layer is similar but learns (or learnt, back when you were first
trying to walk) the appropriate commands and offers "open" (no feedback)
replays of standard motions.

From the amount of "small changes" experienced, and long recovery period, it
seems like there was a lot of damage to the nerves.  Yet my "large scale"
symptoms were not that bad - I could still walk OK, use both hands (although
somewhat crudely - writing was a mess, tying laces tricky).

My guess is that the redundancy and overlap, plus the upper layer of feedback
control, are enough to keep your body working pretty well, even when there's
pretty major damage.

But there's a cost.  Even though that is a subconscious process, it seems to
require significant effort.  Hence the tiredness (both daily, and when
running, which presumably requires extra coordination).

Recovery is through many small, uncoordinated fixes.  At some point they are
sufficient to allow the lower level - replaying learnt sequences with little
feedback - to kick in.  And that's when I could suddenly run further, without

In other words:

  * Redundancy and feedback keeps things working, at a cost.

  * Recovery is progressive, but makes little difference to "macro" symptoms
    until a threshold is crossed, at which point learnt actions work again.


Comment on this post